Real Ghost Stories
Around this time of year, I always like to walk the Village streets and see all the Halloween decorations people put up in their windows, on their stoops, even their roofs. The residents there take it seriously and some are really quite inventive, some professionally done, and a few downright frightening. And of course there was the now famous Halloween Parade held each year. But there are other equally frightening sites to see, real ones where real ghosts, and real stories of horror that still echo through time. Let’s take a stroll…..
One famous haunted spot dates back to the 1790’s on Barrow Street in the heart of the Village. Now an elegant restaurant, One if By Land, Two if By Sea. The building it is housed in was the former carriage house of Aaron Burr. It is said to this day, while enjoying a fine dining experience; you may catch a glimpse of the former Vice President as he ascends the stairs to his balcony. More likely though, you would run into his daughter Theodosia, who was tragically lost at sea on the way to visit him in that very building and has been spotted by scores of diners over the years. Alas, I tried more than once to meet the ghost of my favorite founding father and get a first hand look at his very active daughter, but had to settle for just a superlative (though expensive) dinner instead. Maybe next time.
If you go from there and walk down Sixth Avenue until you get to Spring Street, you will be walking on what in 1799 was known as Lispenard Meadows. And it was in those meadows that a young woman, Gulielma Elmore Sands was found dead at the bottom of a well owned by the Manhattan Company, which coincidently was founded by our friend Aaron Burr with the purpose of bringing much needed fresh water to that part of the city. It was a sensational story in the city at the time, the first murder case tried in court in the new nation, and the suspect Levi Weeks, owing to some powerful connections was defended by two up and coming lawyers, Alexander Hamilton and you guessed it, Aaron Burr. Weeks was acquitted; with a legal team like that, there was little doubt of the outcome. But what makes the whole thing spooky, and eerie still, is the well where Gulielma’s body was found, is still there, the city having grown up around it. You can see it today in the basement of a high end clothing store at 129 Spring Street, guarded by a couple of mannequins (who look pretty darn spooky too). And if you don’t get a chill down your spine looking at that, you are made of sterner stuff than me!.
From Spring Street, walking up Broadway to Washington Place you will find yourself in NYU territory, and one particular building, the Brown Building, is home to classrooms and chemistry labs for the students. But in 1911 it housed the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, employing hundreds of immigrant workers, mostly women. And on March 25th, a fire broke out in the top floors of the building, and when the workers there tried to save themselves, they discovered they had been locked in by their employers. With only one fire escape, and elevators that quickly stopped functioning, the top floors became an inferno. Desperate workers jumped from the windows to the sidewalks below, the same sidewalks you can walk on today. In all, 146 workers perished that day; the owners of the business were charged with criminal negligence. Try walking pass that building today, on those same sidewalks and not feel history reaching up to grab you.
Now for one more ghostly sighting: walking west on Eighth Street will bring you to number 12 Gay Street, a speakeasy in the 1920’s and owned by the city’s flamboyant mayor Jimmy Walker. It is where he kept his mistresses. Many a curious pedestrian has looked up at its windows and spotted a tall figure in top hat and tails looking down on the city, his city. It attracts folks to this day who want to catch a glimpse of his honor, the mayor; it is considered one of the most haunted buildings in the city. And a curious note: later Frank Paris lived there also. And who is Frank Paris, you ask? Well in that very building Frank created the rather famous puppet Howdy Doody (those of you of a certain age will surely know who that is!).
Ok I don’t know about you but after this walk, I could use a drink. Just head west on Bleecker till you get to Hudson, and there you will find one of the most haunted pubs in the city, the famous White Horse Tavern, a perfect place to end this excursion into New York’s haunted past. And heck we didn’t even get to the Merchant House, the Jefferson Market Library, the Cherry Lane Theater or the Waverly Inn, all respectably haunted for many years.
One thing is for sure: no haunted hayride is needed with all the ghosts you can meet taking a walk through Greenwich Village.
Happy Halloween.
-Rob